Blog Article Pet Loss and Disenfranchised Grief

A woman writes to an online pet-loss forum a few days after her 14-year-old dog died. She’s had her since she was a puppy and finds herself going through the motions of life. She can’t seem to enjoy much of anything. Her partner was devastated on the day of the loss, but by the next evening he was frustrated by how much she was still crying. She knows he’s sad too; he just copes differently. Still, she feels completely alone.

Unfortunately, your experience of pet loss can feel dismissing and invalidating in a way that can leave you feeling unseen and confused. My colleagues *Chandler Marr, Sara Kaufman, and I looked at why grief over a pet so often goes unrecognized, and what helps. Here’s a bit of what we discovered.

Why losing a pet hurts so much

For many of us, pets aren’t “just” animals. About 88% of American pet owners consider their pet a true member of the family (Ballard, 2019). Research suggests our bonds with pets can resemble our bonds with parents and siblings, offering comfort, safety, and unconditional acceptance (Kurdek, 2008). Pets give our days routine and purpose, keep us company through illness and loss, come into our lives on purpose and by accident, and connect us to our children, our aging loved ones, and our community.

So, it makes sense that losing a pet can be devastating. The death of a family pet is one of the most common stressors a family faces. Grieving a pet can bring despair, guilt, trouble sleeping, loss of appetite, and even moments of briefly “seeing” the animal that’s gone. The closer the bond, the more intense and lasting the grief tends to be.

Pet loss isn’t only about death. People grieve pets who run away, are stolen, or must be surrendered to a shelter. Those losses can linger for decades, especially for adults where grief and loss were not encouraged or socially sanctioned as children, leaving many with little experience or coping skills to handle this intense grief.

Grief without permission

Despite how deep this loss can run, it often goes unrecognized.

Grief researcher Kenneth Doka calls this disenfranchised grief: grief that can’t be openly acknowledged, publicly mourned, or socially supported. It happens because every culture has unwritten rules about grieving, about who we’re allowed to mourn, how, and for how long. One common rule is that deep grief is reserved for human family members, only, not pets.

These rules show up in everyday messages: “It was just a dog,” “You can always get another cat,” “Shouldn’t you be over this by now?” Workplace bereavement policies often leave pets out entirely. And sometimes the rules are internal. We tell ourselves we shouldn’t feel this sad, and we hide our grief to avoid judgment from others.

Five ways pet grief gets dismissed

Doka (2002) describes five ways grief becomes disenfranchised. Each one shows up with pet loss.

  1. The relationship isn’t recognized. Others don’t see the bond as meaningful. This can be especially painful for people whose animals are also working partners or lifelines, like police officers with K-9 partners, veterans with psychiatric service dogs, or other types of service animals for individuals living with disabilities.
  2. The loss isn’t acknowledged. Friends, coworkers, and even family members minimize the pain. Grief can start before a death. For example, caring for a pet with cancer means losing walks and playtime long before saying goodbye, and that anticipatory grief often goes unseen.
  3. The griever is excluded. Children and older adults are often left out of grieving. Adults may shield kids or older adults from a pet’s death to avoid a hard conversation, but that can distort an understanding of loss. For older adults, a pet may be a daily companion or a last living link to a late spouse.
  4. The circumstances carry stigma. When a loss involves euthanasia, an accident, or surrendering a pet for financial or safety reasons, people may feel guilt or fear judgment. About half of owners who euthanize a pet feel guilty. Many stay quiet rather than ask for support.
  5. The way someone grieves is judged. Crying “too much,” or not crying at all, can each draw criticism. Sometimes, misaligned ways of grieving can cause tension in family relationships.

When partners grieve differently

Grief researchers Terry Martin and Kenneth Doka (2011) describe a spectrum of grieving styles:

  • Intuitive grievers feel grief intensely and express it outwardly: crying, talking, leaning into the pain, and adjusting slowly.
  • Instrumental grievers process grief more through thinking and doing. They tend to grieve privately, stay busy, and try to problem-solve their way back to normal life.
  • Blended grievers combine both, usually leaning one way.

Neither style is better. There’s no right way to grieve. But when two people in the same home grieve differently, each can misread the other. The intuitive griever sees their partner as cold or distant. The instrumental griever sees tears as being excessive or that the partner is stuck.

If you and your partner are grieving the same loss in different ways, try naming your styles out loud. “I need to talk about her” and “I need to keep busy” can both be true. Look for a shared ritual that honors both needs can help each partner understand and acknowledge the grieving process.

Making room for grief

The good news is that grief that’s been dismissed can be “re-enfranchised,” given back its legitimacy, through how we communicate with each other and ourselves.

  • Offer support without fixing. Even well-meaning advice about how to cope can feel dismissive. Often the most supportive message is simple: “I know how much you loved her. I’m so sorry.”
  • Find people who understand. When friends or family don’t get it, pet-loss hotlines, online forums, support groups, and counselors can fill the gap. Some veterinary hospitals now have mental health counselors who specialize in pet loss.
  • Create a personal ritual. Personal rituals are often more meaningful than formal ceremonies. Light a candle, gather photos, write a letter, or donate in your pet’s name. Rituals give grief a container where the pain can be acknowledged, and sharing them with loved ones can ease isolation.
  • Tell the story. Sharing memories of your pet, and the story of the loss, helps you make sense of what happened and carry the relationship forward.

Your grief is valid

Grief doesn’t move in a straight line. Years later, driving past a favorite dog park might bring it all back. That doesn’t mean you haven’t healed. It means the love was real.

If you’re grieving a pet, your grief deserves the same care as any other loss. Let yourself be sad for as long as you need. Look at the photos. Tell the stories. In time, they may bring more smiles than tears.

If pet loss has stirred up more than you expected, or if you and your partner are struggling to grieve together, I’d be glad to help. Reach out to schedule a consultation.

 

*Dr. Chandler Marr is an assistant professor in the Department of Communication at the University of Kentucky. Dr. Sara Kaufman is an assistant professor in the Department of Human Culture and Society at Lindenwood University.

Read the full chapter: Marr, C. T., Kaufman, S. V. A., & Craig, E. A. (2022). Communication and disenfranchised grief: Managing the unrecognized grief of pet loss. In G. Luurs (Ed.), Handbook of research on communication strategies for taboo topics (pp. 459–481). IGI Global. https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-7998-9125-3.ch023

References

Ballard, J. (2019). Most pet owners say their pet is part of the family. https://today.yougov.com/topics/ lifestyle/articles-reports/2019/12/13/how-americas-pet-owners-feel-about-their-furry-fri

Doka, K. J. (2002). Introduction. In K. J. Doka (Ed.), Disenfranchised grief: New directions, challenges, and strategies for practice (pp. 5–22). Research Press.

Doka, K. J., & Martin, T. L. (2011). Grieving styles: Gender and grief. Grief Matters: The Australian.  Journal of Grief and Bereavement, 14(2), 42–45.

Kurdek, L. A. (2008). Pet dogs as attachment figures. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 25(2), 247–266. doi:10.1177/0265407507087958

 

Get In TouchTake the next step.

Schedule a free 15-minute consultation.

Call, text, or connect online.

Book a free consult

(910) 741-5029

Replies within 1-2 business days.

In Crisis?

In an emergency call or text 988 or call 911. This site isn’t monitored for emergencies.